API Gateway vs Service Mesh: How to Choose?

API7.ai

February 27, 2025

API Gateway Guide

Introduction

In modern cloud-native architectures, API gateway and service mesh are two essential technologies for managing service-to-service and client-to-service communications. However, they serve different purposes, leading to confusion when deciding which one to implement.

This article provides a deep dive into their core functionalities, advantages, challenges, and the key trends shaping their evolution—including how Kubernetes' built-in capabilities are making the traditional sidecar model of service mesh less relevant.

By the end of this guide, you'll have a clear understanding of when to use an API gateway, a service mesh, or both.

Core Differences: API Gateway vs. Service Mesh

What Is an API Gateway?

An API gateway is an entry point for managing external client requests to backend services. It provides authentication, traffic control, rate limiting, caching, logging, and more.

Key Features:

  • Request routing and transformation
  • Authentication (OAuth, JWT, API keys)
  • Rate limiting and throttling
  • Security policies (WAF, IP whitelisting)
  • API analytics and monitoring

Use Cases:

  • Handling API traffic from external clients
  • Securing and monitoring public APIs
  • Implementing API versioning and monetization

What is a Service Mesh?

A service mesh is an infrastructure layer for managing service-to-service (east-west) communication within a microservices architecture. It provides observability, security, and traffic control without modifying application code.

Key Features:

  • mTLS-based encryption for secure communication
  • Automatic retries and circuit breaking
  • Service discovery and load balancing
  • Distributed tracing and logging
  • Fine-grained traffic control (A/B testing, canary releases)

Use Cases:

  • Enforcing zero-trust security between microservices
  • Improving observability in complex distributed systems

Choosing Between API Gateway and Service Mesh

When to Use an API Gateway?

✅ You need to manage external API traffic ✅ Security and authentication for public APIs ✅ Load balancing and caching for API requests

When to Use a Service Mesh?

✅ You have microservices communicating internally ✅ You require zero-trust security (mTLS) without modifying application code ✅ You need distributed tracing across services

Best Practices for Implementing API Gateways and Service Mesh

1. Choose a Vendor-Neutral Open-Source Solution

  • API gateway: Apache APISIX (Apache Software Foundation)
  • Service mesh: Istio (CNCF project)

📌 Avoid vendor lock-in by selecting open-source projects with strong community support.

2. Optimize for Performance

  • API gateway: Use caching to reduce backend load
  • Service mesh: Minimize sidecar proxy overhead or explore eBPF-based solutions

3. Secure APIs and Internal Services

  • API gateway: Use OAuth and JWT authentication
  • Service mesh: Enforce mTLS encryption between services

FAQ: Addressing Common Questions

1. Is an API gateway a replacement for a service mesh?

No. An API gateway is designed for handling north-south traffic (external requests), while a service mesh focuses on east-west traffic (internal service communication).

2. Can I use Kubernetes without a service mesh?

Yes. Kubernetes' native security and observability features are making some service mesh capabilities less necessary, especially with Gateway API becoming the new standard.

3. Does a service mesh add latency?

Yes. Traditional sidecar proxies introduce ~5-10ms latency per request. Alternatives like sidecar-less service mesh (e.g., eBPF-based solutions) can reduce this overhead.

4. What is Gateway API, and why is it important?

Gateway API is an emerging Kubernetes standard for defining and managing traffic routing. It provides a vendor-neutral alternative to traditional ingress controllers and API gateways.

Key Takeaway:

🚀 If you need to handle external API traffic, use an API gateway like Apache APISIX. 🔐 If you require internal security and observability, consider a service mesh like Istio. 🌍 If you want future-proof Kubernetes-native traffic management, keep an eye on Gateway API.

For more insights into API management, subscribe to the API gateway Guide series!

Next Steps

Stay tuned for our upcoming column on the API Gateway Guide, where you'll find the latest updates and insights!

Eager to deepen your knowledge about API gateways? Follow our Linkedin for valuable insights delivered straight to your inbox!

If you have any questions or need further assistance, feel free to contact API7 Experts.